skip to main content skip to footer

Catering Menu

Catering Menu

For All Special Occasions! Showers, Graduations, Birthdays, Corporate Parties — Whatever You Are Celebrating.
Great Food “Makes the Party” Let Us Bring It to You!

For All Catering Orders:
• Minimum order of 10 people for buffets.
• Substitutions or special requests are available; additional fees may be required.
• For an additional charge of $1.50 per person we provide: Plates, Bowls, Napkins, Silverware, Cold/Hot Drink Cups.
• Chafing dishes available: $30.00 set up includes sterno for hot foods.
• Chafing dishes require a refundable $25.00 deposit.
• Complete valid credit card information is required to secure the date.
• Delivery is available on orders over $250. The Delivery Fee is $25.00, within Monroe County.
• A Gratuity of 5% will be added to your bill up to a maximum gratuity of $50.00. Anything up to $300.00; $15.00, $300.00-$1,000.00: 5% of Bill, Over $1,000.00: $50.00.
• Servers are available for $35.00 per hour per Server.
• We may not be able to accommodate all last minute requests.
• A final count is required 4 days in advance. The final count cannot be changed.
• Cancellations can be made one week in advance without any fees to your credit card. If you have to cancel less than a week before your event, we will charge your credit card a 25% fee that can be used at a later date for any catering event. This credit can be used up to one year from the date of your cancellation.


Fried Calamari

Full Pan $80.00 | Half Pan $45.00

Clams Casino

Full Pan (50 pieces) $80.00 | Half Pan (25 pieces) $45.00

Scallops Wrapped with Bacon

Full Pan (60 pieces) $90.00 | Half Pan (30 pieces) $50.00

Artichoke Hearts French

Full Pan (50 pieces) $60.00 | Half Pan (25 pieces) $35.00

Chicken Fingers

Full Pan (50 pieces) $65.00 | Half Pan (25 pieces) $40.00

Party Trays

Large Serves 50 | Small Serves 25

Shrimp Cocktail

Large Tray (50 pieces) $85.00 | Small Tray (25 pieces) $50.00


Large Tray $80.00 | Small Tray $45.00

Cheese & Crackers

Large Tray $80.00 | Small Tray $45.00

By The Pan

Full Serves 20 | Half Serves 10

Baked Chicken

Full Pan $80.00 | Half Pan $45.00

Pulled Pork

Full Pan $75.00 | Half Pan $40.00

Chicken Parmigiano

Full Pan $95.00 | Half Pan $55.00

Italian Sausage

Full Pan $75.00 | Half Pan $45.00

Glazed Baked Ham

Full Pan $75.00 | Half Pan $45.00

Baked Pasta

Full Pan $50.00 | Half Pan $30.00


Full Pan $70.00 | Half Pan $40.00

Oven Roasted Potatoes

Full Pan $45.00 | Half Pan $30.00

Tossed Salad

Full Pan $40.00 | Half Pan $25.00

BBQ Chicken

Full Pan $85.00 | Half Pan $50.00

Chicken French with Escarole

Full Pan $105.00 | Half Pan $60.00

Chicken French

Full Pan $95.00 | Half Pan $55.00

Roast Beef

Full Pan $75.00 | Half Pan $45.00

Greens & Beans

Full Pan $60.00 | Half Pan $35.00


Full Pan $85.00 | Half Pan $50.00

Pasta Broccoli with Oil & Garlic

Full Pan $60.00 | Half Pan $35.00

Eggplant Parmigiano

Full Pan $65.00 | Half Pan $40.00


50 for  $90.00 | 25 for $45.00

Dessert Trays

2 Day Advance Notice Required

Assorted Mini Pastries


(2 Pastries Per Person)
Includes: Mini Cannoli’s & Mini Crème Puffs.
Priced per Person

Italian Cookie Trays


(3 Cookies Per Person)
Priced per Person




Per Dozen

Soda Service


Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew & Bottled Water.
Priced per Person

Italian Bread


Per Loaf

Buffet Menus

Includes Food and Serving Utensils Only

Barbecue Buffet


Baked or BBQ Chicken, Pulled Pork, Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad, Baked Beans, Tossed Salad, Sandwich Rolls.
Available for Parties of 20 or More.
Priced per Person

Classic Buffet

Glazed Baked Ham, Italian Sausage with Peppers,& Onions, Chicken French, Chicken Parmigiano, Roast Beef au Jus, Baked Ziti, Oven Roasted Potatoes, Greens & Beans, Tossed Salad with 2 Dressings, Rolls & Butter.
Priced per Person

Choice of 2 Meats $14.49 | Choice of 3 Meats $16.49

Corporate Lunch Buffet


Chicken French, Eggplant Parmigiano, Ziti with Sauce, Tossed Salad, Rolls & Butter.
Priced per Person

Italian Buffet


Chicken Parmigiano, Italian Sausage with Peppers & Onions, Penne in Marinara Sauce, Greens & Beans, Garlic Roasted Potatoes, Tossed Salad with 2 Dressings, Rolls & Butter.
Priced per Person

Deluxe Buffet


Veal Marsala, Chicken French, Penne with Broccoli, Oil & Garlic, Oven Roasted Potatoes, Eggplant Parmigiano, Tossed Salad, with 2 Dressings, Rolls & Butter.
Priced per Person

All prices are subject to NY Sales Tax. All prices are subject to change without notice.
We have Gift cards available at the restaurant and online.
We accept Cash or Visa, Master Card, Discover, & American Express cards. Sorry, no personal checks!
See our Party Menu for service in our restaurant.
Papa Joe’s full restaurant menu is available for takeout.